Job Market Paper
Short Messages Fall Short for Micro-Entrepreneurs: Experimental Evidence from Kenya
This paper studies whether low-touch SMS-based business management training can durably improve managerial practices and business outcomes for micro-entrepreneurs using a large-scale field experiment. Three months after the intervention, I find that the training improved managerial knowledge and practices, with younger entrepreneurs engaging more with the content and experiencing stronger positive effects on business outcomes. However, these positive effects dissipate within twelve months as engagement with the training declines rapidly over time. Despite this fade-out, entrepreneurs exhibit positive willingness to pay for additional training content, suggesting they value access to managerial knowledge. The results highlight sustained engagement as a key constraint to scalable capability-building and suggest limits to information-based managerial interventions as stand-alone tools.
Blog Posts and Policy Briefs:
EconThatMatters
Center for Effective Global Action (CEGA)
The International Growth Center (IGC)
Publications
The Limits of Centralized Accountability in the Public Sector
with Saad Gulzar, Juan Felipe Ladino and Daniel Rogger (Accepted, Nature)
A long-established approach to management in government has been the transmission of information up a hierarchy, and centralized decision-making and oversight; colloquially known as ‘command and control’. This paper examines accountability in such a system implemented at scale in Punjab, Pakistan. Using random variation in the intensity of accountability of the scheme, we show that the corresponding de facto punishments had a negligible impact on school or student outcomes. We use detailed data on the education production function to show that this fundamental component of command-and-control approaches does not induce bureaucratic action towards improvements in government performance.
Working Papers
Hot Bureaucrats: Heat and Effort in Public Administration
with Saad Gulzar, Juan Esteban Garzon, Juan Felipe Ladino, and Daniel Rogger
Climate change imposes large costs on health, productivity, and learning, and governments are the institutions responsible for protecting populations from these costs. Whether extreme heat also degrades the functioning of government itself remains largely unknown. We combine high-resolution satellite temperature data with monthly administrative records covering roughly 42,000 public schools and the 6,000 front-line education officers who supervise them in Punjab, Pakistan. We first document that extreme heat strongly correlates with reduced bureaucratic effort: the probability that an officer fails to visit a school doubles in hot months, and a one standard deviation increase in days above 38C is associated with a 21 percentage point decline in the share of schools visited. Second, we show that the damage is greatest where the state normally works best. Officers cannot predict when the first heat wave of a month will arrive, so its timing operates as a natural experiment, and the more of the month’s visits an officer still has pending when heat strikes, the more work is disrupted. Officers with the strongest performance records in cooler months cut back the most, erasing much of the gap between the bureaucracy’s best and worst performers. Third, schools that lose their monthly visit see teacher presence fall and test scores decline in the month that follows. Extreme heat thus reaches beyond farms, firms, and households to the machinery of government itself, weakening the institutions on which adaptation to a warming world depends.
Selected Work in Progress
“The Political Economy of Environmental Protection: Evidence from India”
with Juan Felipe Ladino and Suraj R. Nair
“Mobile Mentoring: Supporting Education of Vulnerable Children in Kenya”
with Stephanie Bonds and Eric Ochieng
“Accounting for Accounting: Book-keeping Lessons from Nigeria”
with Abiola Oyebanjo and Anne Krahn